Customer success managers and account managers look after the same customers and are often paid as if they did the same job. They do not. One protects revenue you already have. The other grows it. A plan that blurs the two pays for outcomes nobody controls and leaves gaps where nobody is accountable. This guide covers how to separate them, what to measure, and a worked example.
Start With Who Owns What
Before any pay design, write down who owns each of these:
Adoption and health: is the customer using the product and getting value?
Renewal: who negotiates and signs it?
Expansion: who finds the opportunity, and who closes it?
Escalations: who is on the hook when the account is at risk?
Typical splits: the CSM owns adoption and flags risk and opportunity. The account manager owns the commercial conversation, meaning the renewal and the upsell. In smaller teams one person does both, and the plan has to say which matters more.
Retention Measures
Gross revenue retention: recurring revenue kept from existing customers, before any expansion. It cannot exceed 100%. This is the cleanest measure of whether customers stay.
Net revenue retention: the same figure including expansion. One large upsell can hide several lost customers, so it is a weaker measure of retention on its own.
Logo retention: the share of customers kept, regardless of size. Useful when you have many small accounts.
Pay retention roles on gross retention. Pay expansion on expansion bookings. Paying one person on net retention alone lets a good upsell quarter cover for churn.
Expansion Measures
Expansion bookings: added recurring revenue from existing customers. This is the standard for an account manager with a number.
Qualified expansion leads: opportunities the CSM identifies and hands to sales. This fits a CSM who should spot growth without becoming a closer.
Pay Mix
The more the role closes, the more variable it should carry. Commonly cited ranges put CSMs around 80/20 or 75/25 base to variable, and account managers with a renewal and expansion number closer to 70/30 or 60/40. Those are starting points. Set the mix by how much the person controls the result, and test it in the pay mix analyzer.
A Worked Example
These numbers are an illustration, not a benchmark.
Role: CSM with a $3,000,000 book of recurring revenue.
On-target earnings: $120,000 at 80/20. Base is $96,000. Target variable is $24,000.
Retention component, 70% of variable: $16,800 at target. The target is 92% gross retention for the year. Below 85% pays nothing. 85% pays half. 92% pays in full. 96% and above pays 150%. Results in between are prorated.
Expansion component, 30% of variable: $7,200 at target, paid on qualified expansion leads that sales accepts. At a target of 18 a year, that is $400 each.
A CSM who finishes at 94% gross retention sits halfway between target and the top of the scale. The retention component pays 125%, or $21,000. With 20 accepted expansion leads, the second component pays $8,000. Total variable is $29,000 against a $24,000 target.
Account Manager Plans
An account manager with a commercial number looks more like a sales plan. A common shape:
A quota that combines renewal and expansion dollars, or two separate quotas if you want both protected.
A lower rate on renewals than on expansion, since the renewal is revenue you already had.
A gate: expansion accelerators only apply if retention is at or above target. This stops a rep from chasing upsells while accounts leave.
Expect a higher quota-to-pay multiple here than for new-business reps. Quota-to-OTE ratio explains why and how to check it.
Where These Plans Go Wrong
Paying for churn nobody could stop. A customer acquired by a competitor or shut down by its parent is not a CSM failure. Write an exclusions policy in advance, with a short list and an approver.
Double paying. If the AE, the account manager and the CSM are all paid on the same upsell, add up the total. Decide the crediting rules before the first deal.
Uneven books. One CSM with ten large accounts and another with eighty small ones cannot share a target. Set targets by book.
Annual-only payouts. Retention is an annual number, but a year is a long time to wait. Pay quarterly against year-to-date results with a true-up at year end.
Multi-year contracts. A customer who is not up for renewal this year should not count as retained by effort. Measure retention on revenue that was up for renewal.
Team or Individual
When several people touch every account, a team retention measure can be fairer than an individual one. Keep an individual piece wherever you can identify individual work. People stop pushing on a number they cannot move.
The Short Version
Pay retention on gross retention, pay expansion on expansion, and never let one hide the other. Decide who owns the renewal before you write the plan, set targets by book, and write the churn exclusions down before you need them. For how these roles sit beside the rest of the team, see the sales role reference guide and sales manager compensation plans.

